Feds Learned of Gunman’s Anger Toward VTA Five Years Ago

Indications that Samuel Cassidy, identified by officials as the gunman in this week’s mass shooting, harbored anger toward his employer had been discovered by federal officials years earlier, after Customs and Border Protection stopped him as he returned from a trip to the Philippines in 2016.

When officers searched his bags, they found books about terrorism, manifestoes and a notebook detailing how he detested the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, known as the VTA, according to an official who spoke on condition of anonymity to describe the contents of an internal message sent around the agency after the shooting.

The Homeland Security Department, which includes Customs and Border Protection, declined to comment, citing an investigation into the shooting in San Jose. The 2016 incident was earlier reported by The Wall Street Journal.

“Based on recent developments in the investigation we can say that the suspect has been a highly disgruntled VTA employee for many years, which may have contributed to why he targeted VTA employees,” Sgt. Russell Davis of the Santa Clara County Sheriff’s Office said in a statement.

Sheriff Laurie Smith of Santa Clara County described the gunman’s killings as deliberate, though it was unclear whether he chose his victims. None of the people who were shot survived. The sheriff suggested that the carnage, spread out over two buildings, could have been worse if deputies, whose headquarters is next door to the rail yard, had not arrived quickly.

Smith said that the gunman turned to a union representative who was at the site for an impromptu visit and said something like “I’m not going to shoot you” immediately before he began killing his colleagues.

“He was very deliberate, very fast,” she said. “He knew where employees would be.”

The Santa Clara County medical examiner’s office identified the victims as Paul Delacruz Megia, 42; Taptejdeep Singh, 36; Adrian Balleza, 29; Jose Dejesus Hernandez III, 35; Timothy Michael Romo, 49; Michael Joseph Rudometkin, 40; Alex Ward Fritch, 49; Abdolvahab Alaghmandan, 63; and Lars Kepler Lane, 63.

They were part of a close-knit group of workers who helped keep the transit agency’s buses and light rail trains moving. Several were fathers, and they included immigrants from the Philippines, India and Iran.

Balleza, the father of a 2-year-old son, had worked at the VTA since 2014. He had been excited to go fishing with his son one day, his wife said. Singh enjoyed playing volleyball and had moved to the United States from India in 2005. Megia had moved to the United States from the Philippines when he was a toddler and loved to take his two sons, daughter and stepson wakeboarding, his father said. They had planned to leave for a trip to Disneyland on Thursday.

“We don’t know the relationships or the correlations between the victims and the shooter,” said Arturo E. Aguilar, the chairman of the California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union, a labor group that represented the workers who died. The people who died worked in various departments, he added in an interview on the lawn outside the union’s San Jose office Thursday.

As the shooting began, Singh, one of the victims, alerted colleagues: At 6:36 a.m., he called Sukhvir Singh, another employee, with an urgent warning. “Hey! There’s an active shooter,” Sukhvir Singh recalled Taptejdeep Singh saying. “Get out.”

Sukhvir Singh, who specializes in repairing and maintaining the light-rail trains that run through San Jose and is not related to Taptejdeep Singh, fled with crew members to a windowless building that houses antique railroad vehicles. They waited there until it was over.

“He is the hero for everyone,” said Sukhvir Singh, who described Taptejdeep Singh as unfailingly gracious and helpful.

He said Cassidy barely knew Taptejdeep Singh, who worked in a different department as a light-rail operator, and in a different building. “They didn’t have any connection at all,” he said.

For a time, Sukhvir Singh worked in the same building as Cassidy. He would pass him in the halls and say hello, he recalled, and Cassidy might acknowledge him with a grunt. “He didn’t really communicate with other people,” Sukhvir Singh said. “He was in his own world.”

In Santa Cruz, California, Cassidy’s ex-wife, Cecilia Nelms, 64, said Thursday that he was depressed and angry throughout their 10-year marriage. They had not spoken in 13 years, she said.

He proposed three months after they met at a nightclub in Cupertino, California, when Cassidy worked as a mechanic for a Mazda dealership. He loved cars and pets and kept several boa constrictors in addition to the couple’s two dogs. He later began working for the VTA.

Over the years, Nelms said, Cassidy’s personality changed, and he grew meaner, angrier and more impatient. He struggled with depression and took medication for it. He complained about his co-workers at the VTA, grumbling that some were lazy or had easier jobs than he did.

Occasionally, Nelms said, Cassidy would say, “I wish I could kill them.” She said she did not think he was serious.

The couple, who had no children, broke up in 2004 and divorced.

Cassidy lived in a one-story home with white trim and a patchy lawn in the Evergreen neighborhood in a suburban corner of southeastern San Jose. After the shooting, the neighborhood was swarmed with fire and police vehicles, federal agents and a boxy blue truck from the San Jose bomb squad. Men with gas masks and oxygen tanks stood amid the flashing lights in the cul-de-sacs of what they all described as a quiet suburban neighborhood that is home largely to Vietnamese and Filipino immigrants.

Doug Suh, who lives across the street, said Cassidy lived alone and rarely had visitors.

“I was afraid of him,” Suh said. “My wife was scared of him, too.”

Suh recalled Cassidy once lashing out at him when Suh turned his car around in Mr. Cassidy’s driveway. “He yelled, ‘Do <em>not</em> come onto my driveway.’”

On Wednesday after the shooting, Suh scanned through his security camera footage. The camera captured Cassidy at 5:40 a.m. — less than 45 minutes before he opened fire at the rail yard — loading his white pickup truck with a black bag. He was wearing a uniform with reflective stripes.

“What about all these families that lost sons and fathers?” Anthony Nguyen asked in an interview in his driveway. “I’m so sorry for them. It’s not right. All these broken hearts.”

Copyright 2021 The New York Times Company

Kellen Browning, Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs and Patricia Mazzei contributed to this report.


  1. This is horrible journalism. Inflated. Exaggerated. And most of all does not deal with the real issue. Systemic racism on your site, in this workplace, and all around here. The hitman was on his way into a disciplinary hearing… why don’t you even mention that? Smith saying it coulda been worse, what an incompetent buffoon. It shoulda never happened. If they had this “real” evidence, they shoulda held the hearing at the jail house across the street. People would still be alive. Duh. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcbayarea.com/investigations/gunman-faced-vta-disciplinary-hearing-on-day-of-attack/2556757/%3famp

  2. I’m very impressed with Laurie’s combat-ready ensemble, but surprised she happened to be wearing it in the office that awful morning (she did respond directly, no?).

    I thought she just dressed that way in Grand Jury chambers when taking the 5th.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *