Michelle Goldberg: It’s Marjorie Taylor Greene’s Party Now

Michelle Goldberg, an op-ed writer for the New York Times, spent part of her early career as a staff writer for Metro Silicon Valley and its former sister publication, Metropolitan.—Editor

Steve King, the Republican former congressman from Iowa, must feel robbed. Two years ago, he was stripped of all his committee assignments after asking, in an interview with The New York Times, “White nationalist, white supremacist, Western civilization — how did that language become offensive?” The Republican Party threw its weight behind King’s primary challenger, and he was whisked off the national stage, no longer to embarrass colleagues who prefer that racist demagogy be performed with enough finesse to allow for plausible deniability.

Since then, standards have changed. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., is every bit as bigoted as King, and 10 times as unhinged. By now, you have surely heard her theory that California wildfires might have been caused by a space laser controlled by Jewish bankers. That wasn’t Greene’s first foray into anti-Semitism; in 2018 she shared a notorious white nationalist video in which a Holocaust denier claimed that “Zionist supremacists have schemed to promote immigration and miscegenation.”

Recently, Greene met with a far-right British commentator, Katie Hopkins, who has described migrants as “cockroaches” and said she doesn’t care if they die. Greene told her, “I would love to trade you for some of our white people here that have no appreciation for our country.” She described the results of the 2018 midterms as “an Islamic invasion of our government.” Greene endorsed calls for the execution of prominent Democrats and agreed with Facebook posts claiming that the Parkland and Sandy Hook school shootings were hoaxes. She harassed one of the Parkland massacre’s young survivors.

As it happens, this week House Republicans are seeking to punish a prominent woman in their ranks — but it is not Greene. A big chunk of the House Republican caucus is reportedly trying to oust Liz Cheney of Wyoming from leadership because she voted to impeach Donald Trump for inciting the Jan. 6 insurrection.

Kevin McCarthy, the Republican House leader, is meeting with Greene, but it is far from clear that he will act against her because she represents much of their party’s base. When The New Yorker’s Charles Bethea met a group of Greene’s local supporters last year, they were generally familiar with QAnon, and several agreed that Democrats are controlled by Satan. There is a reason Kelly Loeffler, who needed to get out the pro-Trump vote, touted Greene’s endorsement when she was trying to hold on to her Georgia Senate seat.

Some decent Republicans imagine they are in a battle for their party’s soul. Rep. Adam Kinzinger, who like Cheney voted to impeach Trump, recently started a PAC devoted to fighting the forces that led to Greene’s rise and the Capitol rampage. “The time has come to choose what kind of party we will be,” he said in an introductory video. The thing is, Republicans already have chosen.

Just look at the party’s state affiliates. On Jan. 4, the Arizona GOP retweeted a “Stop the Steal” activist who had pronounced himself willing to “give my life” to overturn the election. Said the party’s official account: “He is. Are you?” An Arizona lawmaker has since introduced a bill that would let the Legislature, controlled by Republicans, override the presidential vote of the state’s increasingly Democratic citizenry.

The Oregon Republican Party approved a resolution suggesting that the Capitol siege was a “false flag” attack. The Texas Republican Party has adopted the QAnon slogan “We are the storm” as its motto, though it insists there is no connection. The chair of Wyoming’s Republican Party, who attended Trump’s rally on Jan. 6, said he might be open to secession.

Greene is not the outlier in this party. Kinzinger is.

American conservatism — particularly its evangelical strain — has fostered derangement in its ranks for decades, insisting that no source of information outside its own self-reinforcing ideological bubble is trustworthy.

If you are steeped in creationism and believe that elites are lying to you about the origins of life on Earth, it is not a stretch to believe they are lying to you about a life-threatening virus. If what you know of history is the revisionist version of the Christian right, in which God deeded America to the faithful, then pluralism will feel like the theft of your birthright. If you believe that the last Democratic president was illegitimate, as Trump and other birthers claimed, then it is not hard to believe that dark forces would foist another unconstitutional leader on the country.

There was a moment, after the Capitol riot, when it seemed as if a critical mass of the Republican Party was recoiling at what it had created. But the moment passed, because it would have required the party’s putative leaders to defy too many of their followers. Sen. Mitch McConnell floated openness to convicting Trump in a Senate trial but ended up voting that such a trial was unconstitutional. Fox News, finger to the wind, purged many of its real journalists and gave conspiracy theorist Maria Bartiromo a prime-time tryout.

On Monday, Politico reported that if Republicans don’t strip Greene of committee assignments, Democrats will try to do it, bringing the issue to the House floor. Republican members will have the chance to distance themselves from her. If they don’t, it will be because they know she belongs.

Copyright 2021 The New York Times Company

4 Comments

  1. This is just another lighter-weight Times columnist and predictable robot.

    The GOP has problems but the individual of note stands on her own.

    It’s not as if the GOP is the main site of misbehavior, either. GOP = man bites dog, or woman bites dog in the subject’s case here.

  2. Ever since Nixon successfully corralled a significant share of the White backlash to the civil rights and anti-war movements through a refined “Southern strategy” (https://apnews.com/article/f09ab43bd4232894b0e041f1a5d97f53), the Republican Party has been in a steady descent into race-laced electoralism, nativism and obscurantism. In the 1970s and 1980s the party increasingly adopted racialized messaging and adapted tobacco industry (https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/05/low-tar-cigarettes/481116/) and petroleum industry (www.scientificamerican.com/ article/tobacco-and-oil-industries-used-same-researchers-to-sway-public1/) strategies to undermine science-based policies. The party also doubled down on a hyper-aggressive foreign policy under the influence of neoconservative ideologues (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoconservatism). It’s little surprise that the Republican Party has been dubbed “the most dangerous organization on earth” (https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/noam-chomsky-calls-trump-and-republican-allies-criminally-insane/).

    From the above I conclude that the GOP and its adherents are technically engaged in first and second degree murder. The first is defined as “premeditated killings, the killing of especially vulnerable people (such as children), and unintended killings done while intentionally committing another serious felony.” Second degree murder, on the other hand, is non-premeditated “intentional killings and killings that result from conduct so reckless it shows a grave indifference to the sanctity of human life or the welfare of others” (https://murphylawoffice.org/john-murphy-law-office-blog/77-what-s-the-difference-between-homicide-murder-and-manslaughter.html).

    Goldwater, Nixon, Reagan, Gingrich, the Bushes, the Tea Party, McConnel and Trump are the primordial broth; Marjorie Taylor Greene and Lauren Boebert are the swamp creatures spawned from that soup.